| IN THE NEWS
February 27, 2004
Honourable Dalton McGuinty,
Premier of Ontario,
Feb. 23, 2004
Dear Mr. McGuinty:
I am writing to you on behalf of Equal Voice, a multi-partisan,
national advocacy group for the election of more women, to urge
you to proceed as quickly as possible with your pledged democratic
reforms for Ontario.
We view some of those reforms as essential if more women are to
be elected to the Ontario legislature than the disappointing 21
per cent returned in the most recent provincial vote.
We realize that your reforms are intended to benefit all voters
by creating a more responsive Legislature. But we think that replacing
our first-past-the-post electoral system with proportional representation
would achieve not just a better reflection of the popular vote for
each party —it would also provide a Legislature that more
closely mirrors the makeup of the population. Women now are 52 per
cent of Canadians, but in Parliament and legislatures across the
country they seldom achieve more than about a fifth of seats. Most
other modern democracies have adopted systems of proportional representation
and more women have been elected as a result.
However, countries such as Sweden, Norway and Belgium, where women
have reached high levels of elected influence, do not rely on the
voting system alone. They have also adopted affirmative action measures,
such as alternating male and female candidates on party lists. Equal
Voice is not yet advocating quotas. But we do ask you to consider
the policy of the Labour party in Scotland and Wales, where VOLUNTARY
affirmative action has greatly increased the numbers of elected
women. In Wales, in 1997, the Labour party twinned ridings, requiring
each “twin” to nominate one man and one woman. By last
year’s Welsh Assembly elections, parties no longer felt the
need to employ affirmative action. Women had made the leap into
politics, become accepted—and Wales became the first jurisdiction
in the world to elect 50 per cent women to its national assembly.
At the least, we’d urge Ontario’s political parties
to adopt the policy of the New Democratic Party towards nominating
women. The NDP “freezes” nominations until riding associations
can prove a genuine search has been made for a woman,or a nominee
from another under-represented group. The NDP regularly nominates
more women than the other parties, including your own Liberals.
So we ask you to add a recommendation urging voluntary affirmative
action by political parties to the agenda of your reform commission.
We congratulate you for saying you want to get the influence of
big money out of politics. We’d like to see you extend the
strict limits you are proposing for election and leadership contests
to the nomination process as well. The prohibitive expense of nomination
contests is a major barrier to women at this entry level of politics.
As you know, Ontario is one of five provinces considering electoral
reform. British Columbia, Quebec, New Brunswick and Prince Edward
Island have already launched their citizen forums. We urge you to
do so quickly, and we look forward to an opportunity to present
our views at greater length when Ontario’s consultations are
under way.
Sincerely,
Rosemary Speirs, chair,
Donna Dasko, vice-chair Equal voice, pollster Environics Research
;
Marilyn Mirabelli, treasurer for Equal Voice, consultant; community
activist;
Lesley Byrne, secretary of Equal Voice, communications consultant;
Libby Burnham, Q.C., lawyer; community activist;
Frances Lankin, president and CEO United Way of Greater Toronto,
former MPP;
Beth Haddon, broadcaster, university lecturer;
Olivia Chow, Toronto city councillor;
Kiloran German, president Sage Corporate Communications;
Patricia Dumas, writer and translator;
Kim Donaldson, government affairs consultant;
Annamie Paul, lawyer, activist;
Phyllis Tanaka, executive director Canadian Food Information Council;
Peggy Nash, senior representative Canadian Auto Workers;
Julie Lavertu, political activist, consultant;
Kokila Jacob, journalist;
Diane Williamson, president Digital Wizards Inc.,
Tricia Waldron, senior manager, public sector, Deloitte;
Please reply to: Rosemary Speirs, 1815 Altona Road, Pickering,
Ontario, L1V 1M6, 905-509-2777, or info@equalvoice.ca
cc Michael Bryant, Minister responsible for democratic reform, and
Caroline Di Cocco, Parliamentary Assistant to the minister.
|